For anyone interested in speculating about JP's boon, here's a good list/tool I use when I run my game if you just sort by uncommon: https://donjon.bin.sh/5e/magic_items/
I'd personally pick the Pearl of Power for any caster. Though, specifically for Gale, I would look MIGHTY longingly at the Gauntlets of Ogre Power. 19 strength bird would be nifty as fuck. Same for the Headband of Intellect, though not as much.
That said, what a tense episode. I was going nuts when Adam was putting forth Berg losing his armor again. Would've been so brutal.
Question for Adam: Were those the only 3 boons available, or did you maybe roll randomly on a list of possible ones? If so, how'd you come up with the ideas for the boons for each character?
edit well looks like my question was already kind of answered by "winging it." Good enough!